Hard cover, 645 pages, with colour and black & white illustrations and 68 maps. ISBN 978-615-5766-58-9

Considering the achievements of Hungarian archaeology in the second half of the 20th century, the Archaeological Topography of Hungary programme and the published volumes are, without any doubt, one of the most important endeavours of the profession. The volumes published more-or-less regularly since the 1960s cover a part of Hungary big enough to be considered representative of the whole. Each volume comprises the archaeological record of all historical periods in an administrative unit (district), based on data gleaned through field walking, meticulous archive research, and surveying museum collections. Thus, the methodologically complex programme brought about fundamental changes in the research of the areas concerned, also making them suitable for a large-scale comparative analysis aimed at detecting changes in the condition of the archaeological heritage with time. After the fall of the Communist regime in 1989, the country underwent major transformations, which also affected the programme. The participants managed to publish three more volumes between 1993 and 2012, but during the major waves of institutional reorganisation in the last decade, the programme dropped beneath the radar, and the hope to continue it according to the initial objectives faded gradually away. The Archaeological Institute of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences organised a conference in 2015 to overview the past, achievements, current situation, and future possibilities of the programme. Luckily, the conference manifested in a proceedings volume, enabling this essential and comprehensive knowledge to become part of research and research methodology (BENKŐ, BONDÁR & KOLLÁTH 2017). The presentations and the published studies covered almost all aspects of archaeological and topographic research, providing a firm base for the formulation of a renewed research concept. The renewal has also been supported since the conference by an emerging demand for collaboration by various institutes and fields of research, as all professionals concerned became fully aware back then that being pivotal for the success of this major programme, concerning the archaeological research of the whole country. As the volume reviewed illustrates, cooperation was indeed a key to a successful continuation; however, while general objectives have been clarified and the published volume represents a step forward in the set direction, the other major basis of the programme failed to become realised. While it was announced at the conference that the government would support the programme financially, this, akin to several similar announcements of subsidising diverse fields of science, has remained a promise. This set back the programme considerably, and for a while, it looked like this initiative would join the club of unfinished Hungarian scientific projects. Since then, the Archaeological Institute has undergone several major reorganisations, each of which worsened the perspectives of the programme even more. These circumstances make the publication of a new volume, created in the original spirit of the programme while also renewing its frames, even more extraordinary. The merits of publishing such a volume belong definitely to the management of the Institute, who kept going on with the project amidst successive waves of reorganisation and the continuous transformation of the research network, despite having access to almost no other financial resources but their own. However, it must also be noted that the book results from a collaboration unprecedented in previous decades. The other centre of archaeological and topographic research in Hungary has been the Szeged University (former József Attila University), where it was customary for students for decades to choose the topography research of the outskirts of a settlement for their MA thesis topic. Therefore, when the Archaeological Institute decided to go on with the next volume of the topography series, it was logical to rely on available results from Szeged. The choice to use Katalin Vályi’s dissertation for the core of this volume was also a logical one: while the work was completed decades ago, it assessed the outskirts north of Hódmezővásárhely, a settlement almost the size of a district by itself, comprising both a thorough and precise fieldwork and a meticulous assessment of the gleaned data. However, the numerous authors of the volume – Ádám Bede, Elek Benkő, Adrián Berta, Mária Bondár, Viktor Csányi, Gergely Csiky, Tímea Kiss, Viktória Kiss, Ágnes Kolláth, Bianka Gina Kovács, Gabriella Kulcsár, Tibor Marton, Zsófia Masek, Eszter Melis, Patrícia Mészáros, Dániel Pópity, László Révész, György Sipos, and Miklós Takács – had to completely reassess the results (especially their representation on the included maps) of the fieldwalks conducted decades ago; they applied a fundamentally novel approach in both evaluating the data and drawing conclusions. Besides, naturally, the methodology of archaeological and topographic research underwent a major evolution in the past decades. Thus, the authors of this volume took it upon themselves to use the results of an outdated but essential topography research project to create something that meets today’s requirements of such a work, while also fitting the series of topography volumes, each of which brought something novel to the methodology of the field. All their efforts became manifested in a volume that retains all the important elements of the original project but in a renewed form and supplemented by a body of illustrations which may also be considered novel compared to previous volumes of the series. Thus, this volume is a worthy example of one of the longest-running projects in Hungarian archaeology and a model of how institutions in this discipline can work together at a time when the funds available for basic scientific research have become uncertain in many cases, making it increasingly difficult to go on with the implementation of programmes that have been going on for decades.
Upon picking up this new volume, readers will find everything they are used to in the previous volumes. At the same time, there are entirely new elements in the work. Partly because of the vast boundaries of Hódmezővásárhely and partly because of the new topographical methods, the volume does not cover several settlements of a district (not to mention that districts as administrative units have also been abolished in the meantime). However, regarding the number of sites (694) and finds processed, this volume is in no way inferior to the quantitative indicators of previously published works. The basic unit of the previous volumes, the archaeological site, has also been given a new interpretation: with an eye on the national and international experience of archaeological topography, the authors have reinterpreted the traditional concept of ‘site’. In addition to the sites defined almost exclusively based on surface find (pottery) scatters collected and recorded on fieldwalks (appearing as ‘potatoes’ or ‘amoebae’ – polygons –on maps), research now using a variety of different methods of observation (aerial photography, metal detecting, landscape archaeology, traditional fieldwork, comprehensive surface collection, etc.) does not use the same concept of ‘site’ as that reflected by previous volumes. This is clearly demonstrated by the density maps presented in the volume, which illustrate the new research strategy, discussed in detail in the methodological introduction. All this makes the change in which this volume differs from the previous ones even more understandable and relevant. In addition to the presentation of the sites and the finds, the book also contains a very detailed methodological summary, describing the tools used to generate the results and the possibilities and limitations of the methods applied. This is also important because previously, the research methodology of the Archaeological Topography of Hungary was passed on by word of mouth for long: the original concept developers passed on their knowledge in practice to their colleagues who contributed to each volume, while the following generations of archaeologists largely acquired it as university students. However, for a long time, there was no work summarising in detail the methodology of the fieldwork and the knowledge based on which the archaeologists had worked with archival data, the collections of local museums, or the charters mentioning the medieval settlements in a particular area. Dénes Jankovich-Bésán published the first methodological overviews in the 1990s and later; his works represented a firm conceptual base for the 2015 conference and the renewal of topography research (JANKOVICH-BÉSÁN 1992; 1993; 2010; 2011). This makes the methodological summary and the overview of the framework in which an archaeological and topographic research project may be carried out today in the volume particularly important.
The other, also welcome novelty in the reviewed volume is the overviews of the historical periods concerned, for two reasons. First, a major question of archaeological topography research is what printed or digital form is the best for publishing the results. This issue had been raised before, as the editing of several of the earlier volumes took years, during which the data became partially outdated, thus questioning the relevance of disseminating such information in a printed form. Obviously, the best platform for archaeological data and information related to an area in today’s digital era is an easy-to-access digital database which is also easy to be kept updated. But this volume provides evidence of the relevance of the printed form, too: the basic topographical data, the methodological overview, and the summaries of the historical periods concerned jointly form a coherent whole, a ‘snapshot’ of the author’s knowledge about their chosen topic in the moment of publication. Data change day by day, archaeology’s toolkit is constantly evolving, and our understanding of the past changes with them; therefore, it is instrumental to record the moment when all three may be understood in the context of the others. And this leads us to the other main reason why the presented summaries of the historical periods concerned are justified. Already following the publication of the first topography volumes, it could be seen that the research of the concerned areas and eras underwent a significant quality change due to researchers processing the complex body of archaeological topography, which thus entered the scientific circulation. Several studies and summaries of various archaeological periods based on data available in a topography volume were published. However, it is evident that the researchers who participated in the preparation of such a volume – including especially fieldwork, archival research, and the survey of museum collections – are the best suited for writing these summaries. And so, the ‘quality change’ in research becomes an integer part of topography research instead of remaining one of its consequences. The reviewed volume provides several examples where a systematic evaluation of topographical data has contributed significantly to improving our understanding of general questions, the scope of which points way beyond the study area: the neolithisation, the 10–11th-century AD cemeteries, the medieval settlement network, and many more. In conclusion, the methodological overview and the surveys of the historical periods concerned make this volume more than the previous one, not only in quantity but in quality as well.
The illustrations in the volume also represent a significant novelty; this element is not simply an innovation but was necessary for making the present work up to date. Indeed, the information revolution in all fields of life, including archaeology, has fundamentally changed how we present archaeological information in print (and, of course, digitally). Instead of the sketchy maps of the previous volumes (which, in many cases, represent choices of others than the previous authors or editors), the texts in this volume are accompanied by rich, colourful maps and other illustrations. Here too, of course, one must accept the limitations of the paper version compared with the possibilities of the digital map format. However, bearing in mind the differences between a digital database and a printed work, one can say that the renewed topography volume meets the expectations that one may have of such a work today.
In summary, the newly published topography volume is a continuation of an important archaeological tradition in Hungary, which, at the same time, successfully combines many elements of renewal with tradition. We hope that the future efforts of the Archaeological Institute (adapted to the current conditions and professional needs) will continue to ensure that one of the most important programmes in Hungarian archaeology can continue.
József Laszlovszky
Central European University, Department of Medieval Studies, Cultural Heritage Studies Program
e-mail: laszlovj@ceu.edu
References
Benkő, E., Bondár, M. & Kolláth, Á. (szerk.) (2017). Magyarország régészeti topográfiája – Múlt, jelen, jövő (Archaeological Topography of Hungary – Past, Present and Future). Budapest: Archaeolingua.
Jankovich-Bésán, D. (1992). A felszíni leletanyag szerepe a településrégészetben. Candidate dissertation, manuscript.
Jankovich-Bésán, D. (1993). A felszíni leletgyűjtés módszerei és szerepe a régészeti kutatásban. Régészeti Továbbképző Füzetek 4. Magyar Nemzeti Múzeum. Budapest
Jankovich-Bésán, D. (2010). A Régészeti Topográfia helyzete és jövője. In Benkő, E. & Kovács, Gy. (szerk.), A középkor és a kora újkor régészete Magyarországon. Budapest, 885–894.
Jankovich-Bésán, D. (2011). Terepbejárás. In Müller, R. (szerk.), Régészeti kézikönyv. Budapest, 17–28.